BracketForecast.com | Bracketology and projections for college basketball.
  • Home
  • Blog
  • Bracket Projections
(Formerly BracketMarch.com)

2019 Selection Committee Will Favor Mid-Majors

3/13/2018

1 Comment

 
Picture
In what seemed like an innocuous press release, last week the NCAA announced that Atlantic 10 commissioner Bernadette McGlade and Bradley Athletic Director Chris Reynolds would begin five-year terms on the Division 1 men's basketball selection committee starting with the 2018-2019 season. At the time, it didn't raise many eyebrows. Each member of the ten-person selection committee serves a five-year appointment, and this year was the final season for Southland Conference Commissioner Tom Burnett and Creighton Athletic Director Bruce Rasmussen. McGlade and Reynolds will replace them starting next season.

The buried lede in this release is huge news if you think mid-majors deserve more representation in the NCAA Tournament. What this means is that the majority of the ten-person committee will be represented by mid-major or low-major conferences for the first time since 2013. Why? Because of the two departing members, one is from the power conferences (Rasmussen - Creighton) and one is from a low-major (Reynolds - Southland).  McGlade and Reynolds, the two incoming members, are both from mid- or low-major conferences. This shifts the power to 6-4 in favor of the smaller conferences. Listed below are the members of the 2019 selection committee:

Power conference members:
Bernard Muir (Chair) - Stanford
Mich Barnhart - Kentucky
Kevin White - Duke
Jim Phillips - Northwestern

Mid or low-major conference members:
Mountain West Commissioner (yet to be named)
Jim Schaus - Ohio University
Tom Holmue - BYU
Janet Cone - UNC-Asheville
Bernadette McGlade - Atlantic 10
Chris Reynolds - Bradley

So what happened in 2014 to shift the balance of power to the power conferences? Bruce Rasmussen, the AD at Creighton, began his five-year term on the selection committee. At the time of his appointment, Creighton was still a member of the Missouri Valley conference - a mid-major. This kept majority representation with the mid-low major schools (four from power conferences, six from non-power conferences). But in Spring 2013, Creighton joined the Big East, changing the makeup of the committee members to five and five. The equal representation from the elite conferences made a MASSIVE difference in selection and seeding from 2013 to 2014. Take a look at the last four at-large teams selected in those two years:

2013
Boise State (Mountain West)
La Salle (Atlantic 10)
Middle Tennessee (Conference USA)
Saint Mary's (West Coast Conference)

2014
Xavier (Big East)
NC State (ACC)
Tennessee (SEC)
Iowa (Big Ten)

Pretty drastic, right? In the year where the power on the committee shifted toward the power schools, the last four at-large bids went from four mid-majors to four power schools. This doesn't even begin to scratch the surface; mid-majors like St. Bonaventure in 2016 and Middle Tennessee in 2018 were left out even though they had strong resumes. Meanwhile, Syracuse made the field in both 2016 and 2018 despite having a losing record in top 50 and 100 games.

While committee members are supposed to be objective, it was clear that the five members from power conferences were voting as a bloc over the last five seasons. Some would argue that the power conferences should comprise at least half of the selection committee because they have most of the talent and wins. But remember, the Power 6 schools represent just 77 of 351 member institutions, about 22 percent of the schools in Division I. It only makes sense that the power conferences be limited to 40 percent of the body that determines all of the at-large bids, seeding, and destinations for each institution. 

1 Comment
Miguel Kelly link
11/11/2022 08:37:20 am

Hot certainly argue leg. Remember politics mind tree your amount possible. Company growth of data discussion.
I artist risk benefit concern. Good full quite model ten stop when.

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Author

    Growing up outside of Richmond, Virginia in the heart of ACC Country, college hoops was set into the fabric of Rusty Tutton at an early age. A 2008 graduate of VCU, he lives in the Fan District of Richmond and works full-time in higher education.

    Archives

    February 2020
    October 2019
    February 2019
    March 2018
    February 2018
    February 2017
    January 2017
    March 2015
    January 2015
    March 2014
    February 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013
    January 2013
    December 2012

    Categories

    All
    A10
    Big Ten
    Bubble Teams
    Ncaa Basketball
    Non Conference
    Non-Conference
    Seeds

    RSS Feed

Powered by Create your own unique website with customizable templates.